Crushingly disappointed. I'm bummed. I saw this on DriveThruRpg. I was elated to see a rules light Western RPG. For a buck. Hell Yea!!
Evocative art, check. Awesome genre, check. Great price, check.
Oh God NO!!
Classes. They're called Paths, but yeah, its a Class. Damn..
Hit points. Stamina points in this game. Oh, and a different die type by class. At least you don't get harder to kill by going up in level. I like the re-roll at the start of each session. That I think is a cool idea. The 0 Stamina points table is not bad either. Tying stamina to the Grit attribute I like also.
Ahh... ok, well maybe it can still be cool.
Uh oh, here's something like Armor Class. Damn. Okay, so its Defense score. And, armor somehow makes a person harder to hit. Oh, sorry, "Armour". This right here is the other biggest gripe I have with the D&D combat system. Armor just doesn't work that way in my mind. It makes a person harder to DAMAGE or hurt. Usually it makes someone EASIER to hit, as it slows them down, what with being heavy and all. Ah well.
Skill use and Tasks. Okay, cool, you roll against a difficulty on a D6, adding or subtracting for your skill levels. Ummm, okay. Reasonable. Er... What skills? We got some Paths. No idea what each of these Paths should be able to do. I realize its only 8 pages, so a skill list by Path was omitted. We can figure it out.
The Magic and Special abilities section I like. Got some very cool quirks and perks in there. Well done.
This ain't gonna work for me. I pretty much loathe D&D in all its incarnations. I had no idea what this little game was going to be like before I bought it. Since then, I've been reading Stuart's blog, so, I could have known about Weird West if I'd found the blog first. No big deal, its only a buck, and I like to support people making "small press" type games.
I do wonder why I wouldn't just use the Sixguns and Sorcery section in the AD&D DMG though.
So, if you're in to D&D, and want to play a Western, these rules will be perfect for you. Its really a cool little game. I really really want to like it. Its just not for me.